Wisconsin voters have already begun voting in a race that is sure to shape abortion rights in the state and could help decide who wins the crucial battleground of the 2024 presidential election.
At stake Tuesday is control of the state Supreme Court, and the future of many critical issues the court is likely to decide in the coming years.
Wisconsin’s government is essentially deadlocked on many key issues, with Democratic Gov. Tony Evers often at odds with the near-large majority of Republicans in the state legislature. As a result, the bank has become the decision maker on matters with national ramifications, including elections and absentee voting.
Although the court is technically nonpartisan, the conservatives in the dock hold a 4-3 majority. But with the retirement of conservative Justice Patience Roggensack, that majority is now up for grabs.
the contest is on the way to being the most expensive State Supreme Court race in Wisconsin history. Candidates and outside groups have already spent more than $6 million, an amount that, once the general election is over, will likely exceed record $10 million spent in 2020.
Democrats in the state described the race as the biggest anywhere in the nation this year and focused their message on emphasizing abortion rights and elections, extending a strategy the national party employed last year to keep the Senate and defend against a red party. wave in the house
“The race for the Wisconsin State Supreme Court will determine the future of democracy in Wisconsin, the freedom to access safe and legal abortions, and the knowledge that your vote will not be nullified,” said Wisconsin Democratic Party Chairman Ben Wikler. , In an interview.
In Tuesday’s primary are conservative candidates Jennifer Dorow and Daniel Kelly, and liberal candidates Janet Protasiewicz and Everett Mitchell.
Dorow, a Waukesha County Circuit Court judge, last year presided over the criminal trial of Darrell Brooks, who was convicted of killing six people at a Waukesha Christmas parade in 2021 when he crashed his SUV into a crowd. The case received a great deal of media attention, and Dorow announced his candidacy just days after his sentence ended. Kelly is a former state Supreme Court justice who lost his seat in the 2020 election to liberal Jill Karofsky.
Protasiewicz is a Milwaukee County Circuit Court judge who has been endorsed by the Democratic abortion rights group Emily’s List. Mitchell is a judge on the Dane County Circuit Court.
Changes in Wisconsin voting laws and rules may determine who goes to the White House.
Wisconsin Democratic Party Chairman Ben Wikler
Tuesday’s election will narrow the current field of four to the top two vote-getters, who will advance to the April 4 general election. (That technically means that two similarly aligned candidates could run against each other in the general election, although Wisconsin politicians believe that outcome is unlikely.) The winner of that race is elected to a 10-year term.
Candidates, like the court itself, are nonpartisan, but by taking liberal or conservative positions on various issues and receiving endorsements from the state’s major political parties, they can shift their political allegiances.
This year, however, some Republicans in the state have expressed frustration with how openly liberal candidates have conveyed how they would position themselves on hot-button issues, as well as cases that will go before the court, or are likely to To present themselves. . Those Republicans say judges who wire in this way are effectively betraying their ability to hear cases fairly.
“You’re hearing candidates openly say, ‘I think we should strike down this law,’ which is very different from what we’ve seen in courtroom battles in Wisconsin,” said Brandon Scholz, a Wisconsin-based Republican strategist who is not working with any of the candidates in the race. “If many of these judges have already made a decision on various issues and cases, why bother hearing the case then?”
Abortion has taken center stage in the race. Following the US Supreme Court ruling overturning Roe v. Wade last year, a State Law of 1849 that prohibited abortion in almost all cases came back into force. The law makes performing an abortion a felony, and doctors who perform the procedure face up to six years in prison and thousands of dollars in fines. It makes an exception only to save the mother’s life, but not for her health or for a pregnancy resulting from rape or incest.
Evers, as well as Attorney General Josh Kaul, a Democrat, have said they will not enforce the law, with the latter filing a lawsuit claiming the law is unenforceable. That lawsuit is expected to eventually reach the state Supreme Court, likely giving the court the power to decide abortion rights in Wisconsin.
by Protasiewicz television the ads have focused on her support for abortion rights. One shows her speaking directly to the camera, saying “I believe in a woman’s freedom to make her own decision about abortion,” while a second it features several women promoting that support and criticizing the “extremists” on the other side of the argument. Mitchell has also promised protect the right of women to abortion.
In interviews with local media, Kelly and Dorow have criticized Protasiewicz for openly suggesting how she would fail in such a case, while refraining from saying how they would fail. Dorrow, however, has said that the United States Supreme Court “got it wrong” in Roe v. Wade and that he agreed with the decision to overturn it. Both the candidates have state backed up by groups oppose the right to abortion.
Dorow, for her part, has also received criticism from Kelly. While Dorow has said that he would endorse Kelly in the general election if he advances and she does not, Kelly has repeatedly said that she would not do the same for Dorow. expressing doubts about his conservative credentials. The Kelly and Dorow campaigns did not respond to questions from NBC News.
Dorow has described herself in advertisements as “law enforcement election” and has spoken frequently about his oversight of the Brooks trial.
Meanwhile, Kelly, who was endorsed by then-President Donald Trump in his failed 2020 Supreme Court campaign, has connections to a plan the former president’s allies had devised to reverse the results of the 2020 election by using “fake voters” “
In a statement before the House committee investigating the January 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol, former Wisconsin Republican Chairman Andrew Hitt said he and Kelly had “fairly extensive discussions” about that plan, and reported the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel this week that the Republican party had paid Kelly $120,000 at the state and national levels to advise on “election integrity” issues.
The state Supreme Court will most likely hear various challenges to existing election laws, as well as cases that could relate to recounts, absentee ballots, and other facets of election administration that could have a material impact on the outcome of an election. at odds in the perpetual period. battlefield, including in the 2024 presidential election.
For example, in a 4-3 decision last year, the state Supreme Court found all ballot boxes outside election officials’ offices illegal, a setback for Democrats in the state, who had advocated continuing one of the more lenient rules about mailboxes. that arose during the pandemic. Two years earlier, the court, in another 4-3 vote, narrowly confirmed the results of the 2020 election in the state. Democrats predict similar cases in the future.
“Changes to voting laws and rules in Wisconsin may determine who goes to the White House,” Wikler said, adding that “putting an end” to the rulings of the conservative majority could “expand the path for President Biden’s re-election.” in 2024”.
Other issues that could come before the state Supreme Court in the coming years include challenges to Bill 10, a law signed by then-Republican Gov. Scott Walker that eliminated collective bargaining for most public workers. You might also hear cases about redrawn legislative maps (the current map, which the experts have said is one of the most manipulated in the country, it was approved by the current Supreme Court of Justice of the state last year). As is the case in many states, in Wisconsin, if the Governor and the Legislature cannot agree on legislative maps, the matter falls to the state Supreme Court.
At a candidate forum last month, Protasiewicz struck the maps as “rigged”. Dorow declined to discuss the maps, citing the likelihood of the matter coming up in court again, while Kelly told the forum that he would rely solely on “legal” arguments to determine future maps.
Brian Schimming, chairman of the Wisconsin Republican Party, has said that while Protasiewicz had been “remarkably and offensively public in indicating how he would govern on the dais,” in cases like that, he predicted that such comments would help appeal to Republican voters.
“What comes out of that is a lot of energy on our side,” he said in an interview, adding that those comments helped make it clear that “it’s 25 years of conservative reform on the ballot” in April.
It’s a contrast that he and others predicted would result in voters in a spring election out of the year and negative votes.
“The majority could change,” said Scholz, the GOP strategist, noting that Democrats have not kept a majority on the bench for 15 years. “This is for all the marbles.”

