The top US diplomat in Afghanistan has apologized for suggesting that Afghan women might find inspiration for their fight against Taliban oppression in the #BlackGirlMagic social media movement.
“Sometimes our best intentions go awry because we haven’t listened enough or really understand the lived experience of others,” Karen Decker, chargé d’affaires for the US mission in Afghanistan, he said Thursday on Twitter. “My efforts to celebrate brave African Americans this month fall into that category. I apologize to each and everyone I may have offended or hurt.”
Decker had drawn the ire of several high-profile social media users with her tweet this week, which many interpreted as a downplaying of the experience of Afghan women who have seen their freedoms reversed since the Taliban returned to power in 2021.
Female students have been banned from universities, as well as middle and high schools, with women restricted from most jobs, banned from parks and gyms, and forced to wear face coverings in public under strict rules.
“Are Afghans familiar with #BlackGirlMagic and the movement it inspired?” Decker wrote in the now-deleted tweet Wednesday, which was shared widely online by activists, academics and journalists. “Do Afghan girls need a similar movement? What about Afghan women? Show me, ready to learn,” Decker continued, tagging recording artists Beyoncé, Lizzo and Oscar-winning actress Regina King.
The comments sparked a quick reaction online.
“I don’t think many girls in Afghanistan are familiar with #BlackGirlMagic but definitely [have] it made it difficult for the Taliban to sleep day and night,” wrote Fowzia Koofi, who was elected to the Afghan National Assembly and later became Parliament’s first deputy speaker. She left the country for Britain in September 2021 during the Taliban takeover. “There is a need to lift them up and amplify their voices, and the Taliban have expedited their arrest,” Koofi added.
Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, weighed in on the online discussion. “And they said that the adults were in charge again…”. he tweeted on Thursday.

Decker’s tweet was one of the few in which she referred to both Black History Month and the plight of Afghan women in Taliban-ruled Afghanistan.
He also faced a mild rebuke within the Biden administration, which has been criticized for his withdrawal from Afghanistan and subsequent approach to the issue.
State Department spokesman Ned Price told a briefing on Wednesday that the tweets were written by Decker alone and were not approved by the department.
“I will say there are sentiments in his tweet thread that one can appreciate,” Price said. “I think the messages in this context are quite inappropriate and ineffective, and they are not messages that we would put out from here.”
For some, Thursday’s apology was too small, too late.
“Protip: stop tweeting and process the SIVs,” he tweeted. Simone Ledeen, senior fellow at the Krach Institute for Technological Diplomacy at Purdue, referring to special immigrant visas that allow Afghans who helped the US during the war in Afghanistan to leave the country.
Afghanistan’s economy is now on the brink of collapse, with millions unemployed and on the brink of starvation, a severe humanitarian crisis exacerbated by a harsh winter.
