Trump ally advances in Wisconsin Supreme Court race

Trump ally advances in Wisconsin Supreme Court race

A Donald Trump ally who advised Republicans on legal efforts to quash the 2020 presidential race has advanced to the Wisconsin Supreme Court general election, moving him one step closer to a seat on the powerful bench.

Daniel Kelly is a former state Supreme Court justice with connections to a scheme hatched by allies of the former president to reverse the results of the 2020 Wisconsin election through the use of “fake electors.” He was one of two candidates who advanced in Tuesday’s Supreme Court primary, according to projections by The Associated Press.

The other to advance was liberal candidate Janet Protasiewicz, a Milwaukee County circuit judge who was endorsed by the Democratic abortion-rights group Emily’s List.

Protasiewicz and Kelly will face off in the April 4 general election that will determine political control of the court and, with it, the future of many critical issues the court is likely to decide in the coming years, including abortion rights, elections and electoral manipulation. . The winner is chosen for a period of 10 years.

Although the court and its members are technically independent, the Conservatives hold a 4-3 majority. But with the retirement of conservative Justice Patience Roggensack, that majority hangs in the balance.

There hasn’t been a liberal majority on the court in 15 years, and Democrats see the election as an excellent opportunity to shift the balance.

Kelly was one of two conservative candidates in the primary election; the other, Jennifer Dorow, is a Waukesha County circuit judge best known in the state for having presided over the criminal trial of Darrell Brooks, who was convicted last year of killing six people in a Waukesha Christmas parade in 2021 when he crashed his SUV into the crowd.

Protasiewicz won about 46% of the vote Tuesday, a landslide victory based on Democratic turnout, particularly in Milwaukee and Dane counties, which was especially high for an off-year, down-voted winter primary.

The two Liberal candidates in the race together won 54% of the vote, compared to 46% for the two Conservative candidates combined.

Kelly only narrowly edged out Dorow for second place, and the two basically split the support of voters who voted for a conservative candidate. Kelly outperformed Dorow in rural counties, while Dorow outperformed Kelly in heavily Republican suburban counties surrounding Milwaukee.

Kelly is a former state Supreme Court justice who lost her seat in the 2020 election to liberal Jill Karofsky. He was appointed to the post in 2016 by former Republican Gov. Scott Walker. He has remained linked to Trump allies through a scheme that sought to reverse the results of the 2020 presidential election in the state through the use of “fake voters.”

In a statement before the House committee investigating the January 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol, former Wisconsin Republican Party Chairman Andrew Hitt said he and Kelly had “quite extensive conversationsabout the plan, and reported the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel last week that the state and national Republican Party had paid Kelly $120,000 to advise him on “election integrity” issues.

A spokesman for Kelly’s campaign did not respond to questions about his involvement in those efforts. Kelly’s spokesman, Jim Dick, told the Journal Sentinel that Kelly “believes that Joe Biden is the duly elected president of the United States.” Dick also suggested to the newspaper that Kelly’s beliefs about the choice were not necessarily aligned with what her clients believed, saying, “It is a maxim in the legal profession that clients’ opinions cannot be attributed to their lawyers.”

Kelly based much of his campaign on strong criticism de Protasiewicz for having openly suggested how he would adjudicate in crucial cases likely to come before the court involving hot-button issues with national ramifications, such as abortion rights, elections and gerrymandering.

Protasiewicz, one of two liberal candidates in the race (the other was Dane County Circuit Judge Everett Mitchell), campaigned largely on her support for abortion rights. His television The ads, for example, emphasized that support: one showed her speaking directly to the camera and saying, “I believe in a woman’s freedom to make her own abortion decision,” while another second it featured several women touting that support and criticizing the “extremists” on the other side of the argument.

The theme has taken center stage in the race. After the US Supreme Court struck down Roe v. Wade last year, an 1849 State Law the ban on abortion in almost all cases came back into force.

Gov. Tony Evers and Attorney General Josh Kaul, both Democrats, have said they will not enforce the law, and Kaul has filed a lawsuit claiming it is unenforceable. The lawsuit is expected to eventually reach the state Supreme Court, likely giving the court the power to rule on abortion rights in Wisconsin.

Kelly, who has refrained from saying how she would decide in such a case, was backed up for three groups who oppose the right to abortion.

The court is also likely to hear various challenges to existing election laws, as well as cases that could relate to recounts, absentee ballots, and other facets of election administration that could have material impacts on the results of close field elections. of perpetual battle, including the 2024 presidential election.

For example, in a 4-3 decision last year, the state Supreme Court found all ballot drop boxes outside election officials’ offices illegal, a setback for Democrats, who had advocated preserving one of the rules. more lenient about mailboxes that have sprung up during the coronavirus pandemic. Two years earlier, the court, in another 4-3 vote, narrowly confirmed the results of the 2020 election in the state. Court observers predict similar cases in the future.

Other issues that could come before the court in the coming years include challenges to Law 10, a law signed by then-Republican Gov. Scott Walker that eliminated collective bargaining for most public workers. You might also hear cases about redrawn legislative maps (the current map, which the experts have said is one of the most manipulated in the country, it was approved by the current Supreme Court of Justice of the state last year). As is the case in many states, in Wisconsin, if the Governor and the Legislature cannot agree on legislative maps, the matter falls to the state Supreme Court.

The general elections are on the way to being the most expensive Supreme Court race in Wisconsin history. Candidates and outside groups have already spent more than $9.2 million, an amount that, through the general election, will clearly exceed the record $10 million spent in 2020.

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like