The Defense Department is blocking the US government’s efforts to share evidence of possible Russian war crimes in Ukraine with the International Criminal Court, a senior US diplomat told lawmakers on Wednesday.
Beth Van Schaack, the State Department’s ambassador general for global criminal justice, told a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing that the Pentagon continues to delay US cooperation with the Hague tribunal in its investigations of alleged atrocities in Ukraine.
When Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., asked Van Schaack if it was the Pentagon that “isn’t cooperating like that,” she replied: “Yes.”
The Pentagon has harbored concerns that cooperation with the International Criminal Court could lead to the prosecution of US troops deployed abroad. The New York Times first reported in March, the Pentagon’s reluctance to share information about Ukraine with the ICC.
The ICC opened an investigation into possible US crimes in Afghanistan in 2017. The Trump administration immediately expressed outrage and imposed sanctions on the court prosecutor. Court officials later announced that the case against US forces in Afghanistan would receive lower priority.
Van Schaack argued at Wednesday’s hearing that sharing relevant information about alleged war crimes in Ukraine with the Hague tribunal would not create potential legal risks for US troops. He also vowed to fight any such effort by the court.
“I will say up front that in my role as the top diplomat in the international justice space, I would work tirelessly to ensure that no US personnel are brought before the ICC,” he said. “I don’t think that’s an acute risk at this point.”
The ICC also assured US officials that if the US legal system addresses possible war crimes committed by US troops, the court in The Hague would see no need to intervene, it added.
“I don’t think,” he said, “that we are in any way undermining our ability to robustly protect ourselves against any charges that may come.”

