Among all the reasons Joe Biden defeated Donald Trump in 2020 but Hillary Clinton didn’t four years earlier, one is especially important for the upcoming presidential election: the share of third-party votes.
In 2016, 6% of all voters cast ballots for write-in and third-party candidates, with Libertarian Gary Johnson garnering over 3% of the national vote and Green Party candidate Jill Stein capturing over 1%.
But in 2020, that proportion fell to 2%.
The difference effectively changed the threshold that top candidates had to meet to win key battleground states: from 47% and 48% in 2016 to 49% and 50% in 2020.
That, Democrats say, made it easier for Trump to win in 2016, but not in 2020. And the numbers illustrate why Democratic groups, seeking a possible if not likely rematch between Biden and Trump, want to keep third-party votes as small as possible, including moving to keep the well-funded third-party group No Labels. off the ballot in battleground states.
When comparing the results from 2016 and 2020, what stands out is that Trump’s share of the vote (nationally, in battleground states, and in key counties) remained largely the same, even as he won an election and lost another. What changed is that Biden increased the Democratic Party’s vote share by 2 to 3 points across the board, while the protest vote for other candidates fell.
Take battleground Pennsylvania, for example: Trump defeated Clinton in the state in 2016, 48.2% to 47.5%. But as the third-party vote dwindled in 2020, Biden won it, 49.9% to 48.7%.
The same situation developed in Wisconsin. Trump captured battleground status in 2016, 47.2% to 46.5%. But in 2020, Biden 49.5%, Trump 48.8%.
Another way to look at the third-party effect: The 2020 NBC News exit poll found that 5% of national voters said they voted for third-party candidates in 2016, and those voters voted for Biden over Trump by more than 2 to -1 ratio.
That was in an election in which Biden defeated Trump by just 20,000 votes in Wisconsin and by about 10,000 votes in Arizona and Georgia.
“There is no question that Stein and Johnson cost Clinton the election in 2016, and a credible third-party vote could do the same for Biden in 2024,” said Matt Bennett, Third Way’s executive vice president of public affairs. a centrist Democratic group that opposes No Labels’ effort to enter next year’s presidential race.
But No Labels and other third-party groups say there should be more choice for voters, especially when polls show the vast majority don’t want Biden or Trump to run.
“Two-thirds of the public don’t want the election we’re likely to have,” said Ryan Clancy, chief strategist at No Labels.
It all raises important questions for the 2024 presidential election: Will third-party vote sizes approach those of 2016? Will it look more like 2020? And could that affect the outcome of another presidential election?
‘Either you are in favor of democracy or not’
The strategists behind No Labels believe there is a hunger for an alternative to Biden and Trump, and are spending $70 million to launch an independent unity ticket (with one Democrat and one Republican) that could gain access to ballots in all 50 states. , and that I could win, they say.
Getting a non-majority party candidate on the ballot can be complicated, time consuming and expensive. But the group already has access to ballots in Alaska, Arizona, Colorado and Oregon.
According a No Labels survey commissioned and published in March59% of registered voters nationwide said they would consider voting for a moderate independent candidate if the choices were Biden and Trump, including more than half of Democrats and Republicans, as well as 7 in 10 independents.
Additionally, the No Labels poll found that in a three-person race, an unnamed moderate independent candidate wins the support of 20% of all voters, compared to 33% for Trump and 28% for Biden.
No Labels leaders stress that if they don’t have a path to victory, they will ultimately not submit a ticket to 2024.
They also dismiss complaints that their third-party candidacy would disproportionately take votes away from the Democratic ticket, saying their own polls showed that an equal proportion of Democrats and Republicans supported an unnamed moderate independent candidate over Biden and Trump.
“Sitting where we are and saying we know exactly how an independent ticket would impact a race is a selective choice,” said No Labels’ Clancy.
Democrats disagree, pointing to No Labels’ own poll, which showed Trump’s lead over Biden increased from 1 point in a two-person race to 5 points when it included that moderate independent candidate.
And No Labels strategists denounce Democratic efforts to remove him from the ballot, such as in Arizona, where the state Democratic Party sued to deny him access to the ballot.
Clancy said Democrats present themselves as “protectors of democracy,” but argued that efforts to keep No Labels off the ballot, and limit presidential options to just two parties, go against democracy.
“You’re either for democracy or you’re not,” Clancy said.
‘This is one of the easiest ways for Donald Trump to become president’
Democrats opposed to No Labels argue that the third-party group has no chance of winning in 2024.
“No third-party candidate has come remotely close to winning, including Theodore Roosevelt, who ran on a Progressive Party ticket just four years after leaving office as a hugely popular Republican president.” wrote leaders from Democratic groups from the centrist Third Way to the more left-leaning MoveOn.
Instead, they believe an unlabeled candidacy poses a real danger to Democrats, given the very close margins in today’s election and the track record of what happened in 2016.
“I think this is absolutely one of the easiest ways for Donald Trump to become president,” said Navin Nayak, president of the Center for American Progress Action Fund, another Democratic-leaning group that opposes No Labels. Nayak also worked on Clinton’s 2016 campaign.
(That said, third-party candidates, especially from the Libertarian Party, have helped previous Democratic campaigns. When Biden won Wisconsin in 2020 by 20,000 votes, the Libertarian candidate got nearly 40,000 votes.)
Despite polls showing dissatisfaction with Biden and Trump as the nation’s top two choices in 2024, Nayak believes the third-party vote next year will look more like it did in 2020 (when it was 2%) than it did in 2016 (when it was 6%).
One reason is that Biden, even with relatively low approval ratings, does not produce the same level of electoral opposition that Clinton did in 2016.
Another is that fewer Americans, Nayak said, are willing to play games with Trump now than before he became president.
“I think a lot of people thought I was casting a third-party vote with no consequences in 2016,” he said.
But No Labels isn’t the only third-party group that could be on the ballot next year.
Richard Winger, editor of Ballot Access News and a third-party US policy expert, expects the Libertarian Party to be on the ballot in most states, and expects the Green Party to qualify in about half of the country.
But he said it’s impossible to estimate, at least at this early stage, how big the third-party vote will be in next year’s elections.
“It’s really impossible to predict,” Winger said. “There is so much time, and so many things could happen.”

