Contents
The federal grand jury that has been hearing evidence in the Justice Department’s investigation into former President Donald Trump’s handling of classified documents is expected to meet again next week in Washington, according to several people familiar with the investigation.
Prosecutors working for special counsel Jack Smith have been presenting evidence and witness testimony to the grand jury for months, but activity appears to have slowed in recent weeks based on observations in court and sources.
It is unclear whether prosecutors are prepared to seek an indictment at this time. The Justice Department had no comment on the status of the investigation.
According to reports by NBC News and other outlets, prosecutors face two central legal questions: 1) Did Trump improperly withhold classified documents after leaving the White House? 2) Did he later Obstruct the government’s efforts to recover them?
If Smith decides to impeach Trump, it would be the first time a former president has been charged with a federal crime. Although Trump has already been charged in New York with state crimes related to secret payments, the cases differ dramatically.
Trump maintains that he has not broken any laws and continues to criticize Smith and the Justice Department, dismissing the investigation as a politically motivated smear campaign. Here’s what we know, what we don’t know, and what we need to watch as this unprecedented legal case unfolds.
What are the facts?
In June 2022, federal agents traveled to the former president’s home in Florida to recover documents from his time in the White House, at least some of which they believed to be classified. Trump’s lawyers turned over 38 classified materials to authorities and certified in writing that they had conducted a diligent search.
After visiting Mar-a-Lago and obtaining evidence that no additional classified documents had been returned, Justice Department officials obtained a search warrant from a judge and FBI agents searched Mar-a-Lago in August 2022. In total, the Department of Justice recovered more than 300 documents with classified marks.
Trump’s lawyers previewed his defense case ia letter to congress this year, writing that the documents ended up in Florida because White House staff “just swept all the documents off the president’s desk and other areas in boxes.” But it’s unclear whether Smith’s investigation has uncovered evidence to the contrary.
What crimes could Trump be charged with?
Clues as to what precise crime or crimes Smith has been investigating can be found in court documents, including the search warrant and accompanying documentation. sworn declaration filed by the DOJ. There are two basic categories: 1) offenses related to the handling of classified documents and 2) offenses related to obstructing investigators from recovering those materials.
Prosecutors cited the Espionage Act, which conjures up the image of someone acting as a spy for a foreign country. But statute, enacted after World War I, is broader. It criminalizes anyone with “unauthorized possession” of “national defense” material who “deliberately” retains it. A series of court decisions have concluded that even if a document is not technically “classified,” someone can still be charged under the law, as long as the information is “secret” and useful to US adversaries.
Lawyers for the Department of Justice also raised the possibility of a offense related to obstruction in court records. But that law only applies if prosecutors can show that Trump’s intent was to “impede, obstruct, or influence the investigation.” If Trump is charged with obstruction, it will be important to see what specific evidence Smith’s team has gathered about the former president’s intent.
Prosecutors also do not have to limit their case to the crimes explicitly described in the search warrant. recent reports from the Washington Post about Trump “sometimes” showing classified documents to others raises the question of whether he could be charged under an entirely different statute,”disclosure of classified informationwhich prohibits the disclosure of certain classified material to anyone who is not authorized to receive it.
What is Trump’s most likely defense?
Since the raid, Trump has claimed that he had the power to declassify all he wanted, that he had a “standing order” to declassify documents, and that he could declassify materials simply.”think about it.”
While there has never been a case like this before, and no former president has made such claims or been charged with such conduct, most national security lawyers say Trump’s argument is not legally compelling.
His broad power to declassify materials ended at noon on January 20, 2021, once he was no longer president. But let’s assume, for argument’s sake, that Trump declassified the information in his mind while he was flying the plane from Washington to Florida. Attorney Bradley Moss says he still would have had to make that decision in some meaningful way.
“A verbal order doesn’t do it. A tweet does not. There has to be follow-up documentation through the agencies that clarifies what is being declassified,” Moss told NBC News. “If not, anyone who saw it would still have to treat it as classified.” But, Moss warned, there is no precedent for something exactly like this case.
Many have pointed to the fact that Smith could avoid a battle over whether the documents were declassified by charging under the “national defense” material law, but Trump would likely argue that he withheld materials he believed he had a right to possess. “His best defense of him is that he didn’t realize they were classified documents because he didn’t package them up,” Moss added.
On an obstruction charge, Trump could argue that he relied on the advice of others, believed his team was complying with demands to return the documents, or others, like his valet Walt Nauta, who moved the boxes, rebelled.
Where are Trump’s legal vulnerabilities?
Claims that Trump was unaware of how the documents got to Mar-a-Lago are undermined by the fact that he withheld them, even after the government repeatedly asked for them, says Mary McCord, a former acting assistant attorney general for Homeland Security at the Department of Justice and a contributor to NBC News/MSNBC.
“I had received an application and then a subpoena,” McCord said. “If the Archives said we need the documents and he returned everything right away, we wouldn’t be talking about criminal culpability.”
But that is not all. Recent news, first reported by CNN, of Trump speaking on tape about a classified document he kept after leaving office and wishing he had declassified also hurts his case significantly. “It sort of locks him in,” McCord added. “It shows that he really knows that he can’t show documents to unauthorized people.”
The recording could also be key to rebutting any defenses Trump may raise about previously declassifying everything he took after leaving office.
Does Trump’s motivation for keeping the documents matter?
No. “Motivation is irrelevant,” Moss said. Even if Trump wanted to keep classified documents in Florida, not because he planned to give them to a foreign adversary, but simply as a memento of his time as president, he could still face criminal charges.
In 2017, the Justice Department charged a former defense contractor, Harold Martin, with improperly withholding national defense information. There was no evidence that Martin intended to share the materials with anyone, but the amount of information he kept at his house was described as “amazingFormer federal prosecutor in Maryland Robert Hur, who prosecuted Martin, now serves as special counsel investigating President Joe Biden’s handling of classified materials.
Could Trump’s case go to trial before the 2024 election?
It’s hard to say, especially without an accusation. What is clear is that Trump’s legal team would reject any charges and would undoubtedly try to delay the trial.
First, they would likely file multiple pretrial motions to have the case dismissed. And if that didn’t work, their lawyers could file appeals, which would drag out the process even further.
Trump is already facing trial in March 2024 in the New York secret money case. Soon we can find out if he will face another.

