The bipartisan debt limit bill that Congress passed this week contains tougher work requirements for those receiving food assistance, along with new exemptions that could expand access to others.
Under the new rules, which President Joe Biden is expected to sign into law soon, the age of participants in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, who must provide proof of work is raised from 18-49 to 18-54. . That means many poor Americans in their early 50s without a disability or dependents to care for could lose their eligibility or face new bureaucratic hurdles to prove they qualify.
At the same time, the bill also exempts veterans, the homeless, and youth over the age of foster care from SNAP work requirements, an exception that the White House and Democrats have touted. like a win. (Nonpartisan federal investigators project that changes to the debt limit bill would slightly expand the SNAP balance by about 0.2%or about 78,000 people, in an average month).
Many conservative leaders and think tanks argue that tougher requirements are necessary to get more unemployed Americans into the workforce, especially in a historically tight job market that continues to add jobs at a startling rate. But an NBC News analysis of the Census Bureau and other data paints a more complicated picture.
For starters, most families using SNAP, where the average monthly benefit is around $230 per person, are already working, and poverty, not unemployment, is the main challenge they face.
More than 42.5 million Americans use federal food benefits, federal data shows, and 4 in 5 households in the program have at least one family member working.
In some cases, a family may have multiple adults, some working and some not. Experts like Ed Bolen of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), a left-leaning Washington think tank, say that in such families, adults who are not part of the labor force are often involved in other forms of work. such as children or the elderly. careful. Angela Rachidi of the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), a DC-based center-right think tank, said data on the households of several healthy childless adults is lacking, but said she thinks the proportion would be small.
“This idea of an underclass that doesn’t work is very much a cultural myth,” said labor economist Kathryn Anne Edwards, who noted that most families in poverty don’t stay there for long. Edwards pointed to temporary workers, as well as those with other jobs with unpredictable hours, as a common type of SNAP recipient: people who need the program to get themselves and their families through a rough patch.
“It could be that you’re moving from one job to another, it could be that your hours are going up or down, it could be that you’re putting in overtime, you’re missing overtime,” Edwards said.
Bolen, director of SNAP Strategies at CBPP, points out that poverty share and SNAP participation follow each other, rising and falling in tandem. The unemployment rate, on the other hand, often differs from SNAP enrollment.
Many Republican lawmakers and conservative economists say the data is incomplete. Rachidi, a senior fellow at AEI, pointed to a report from the US Department of Agriculture that found that the median length of SNAP eligibility for all participating households was 15 months. This figure includes the elderly and disabled who may be certified for longer periods.
“Length of stay [on SNAP] is the important thing,” Rachidi said, adding that his research indicates about 1 in 4 SNAP recipients are able-bodied adults who “seemingly have no other reason for not working.”
But even length-of-stay data can be misleading. While, for example, 16.4% of American households participated in SNAP during an average month in 2022, many of the households that received benefits in January may not necessarily be the same as those that received them in June.
This idea can be tested by looking at data on SNAP recipients who are not elderly or disabled from a Census Bureau panel covering the years 2009-2013. Even under the strictest beneficiary conditions, the pool of unemployed people receiving SNAP in January 2012, including those with working spouses or child and elder care responsibilities, dropped by approximately 25% by the end of that year, indicating a buoyancy in SNAP eligibility and employment.
As the Biden administration repeatedly noted during debt-limit talks, work requirements for safety net programs have been a feature of the SNAP program for decades, enjoying bipartisan support, including from then-Senator Biden, in the time President Bill Clinton signed sweeping welfare reforms. into law in 1996. But Democrats have generally resented the policies in recent years, even as Republicans in Congress and at the state level continue to look for ways to toughen them.
House Republicans included tougher requirements in the party-line debt limit bill they passed in April, Chairman Kevin McCarthy said late last month that the rules “allow people to go back to work.”
However, Bolen, of the CBPP, said that “people are going to want to work because they will get much more in paid employment than they will through SNAP.”
He likened the show to a “bridge between jobs”. for many people who rely on it intermittentlyparticularly those in “volatile industries” with high turnover.
“It’s not uncommon to see someone working at a restaurant and then they get fired after three months,” he said, “but then they find a job three months later, four months later, at another restaurant.”

