WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday weakened a landmark water pollution law by ruling that an Idaho couple’s property does not include wetlands subject to federal oversight under the law.
The ruling, in which all the justices agreed on the outcome but differed on the legal reasoning, concluded that Mike and Chantell Sackett’s land does not fall under the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act of 1972, and therefore does not require a permit. federal to build on the land. property. The decision ends a year-long battle between the Sacketts and the federal government and is a victory for conservative groups and business interests that oppose widespread enforcement of the water pollution law.
Reaching its broader legal conclusion, the court ruled by a 5-4 vote in an opinion written by Conservative Justice Samuel Alito that the Clean Water Act’s jurisdiction extends only to wetlands that are “indistinguishable” from larger bodies of water by having a “continuous surface”. Connection.”
The wetlands on the Sacketts’ property, he wrote, are “distinguishable from any possibly covered water.”
The ruling will ease some of the burdens on landowners, including major business interests, Alito said, because the law “may be broad enough to criminalize mundane activities like moving dirt.”
Conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh joined the court’s three liberal justices in disagreeing with the new majority test.
“By reducing wetlands law coverage to only contiguous wetlands, the court’s new test will leave some long-regulated adjacent wetlands no longer covered by the Clean Water Act, with significant repercussions for water quality. and flood control throughout the United States,” he said. he wrote.
Under the court’s new approach, the ability to regulate the levee system on the Mississippi River and effectively oversee the Chesapeake Bay could be threatened, Kavanaugh said. The levees dividing the Mississippi River wetlands mean those wetlands could be out of federal oversight and wetlands vital to the Chesapeake Bay could be filled in without federal permits, he said.
In a separate opinion, liberal Justice Elena Kagan took aim at the majority for rewriting a statute that Congress had enacted. She compared the ruling to a court decision last year to limit the scope of the Clean Air Act as part of efforts to combat climate change.
“The vice in both instances is the same: the self-appointment of the court as national decision-maker in environmental policy,” he said.
The case saw the Sacketts return to the Supreme Court for a second time after judges ruled in their favor in a previous case in 2012. Both cases involve the same underlying dispute: their effort to build property on land they own in Priest Lake, Idaho, parts of which the EPA has deemed a protected wetland, meaning the land is subject to federal jurisdiction and construction requires a permit.

The legal dispute centered on whether the Sacketts could challenge an EPA enforcement order in court after they filled the affected area with gravel and sand without obtaining a permit. The fight, which began in 2007, continued over whether the land was a wetland.
The Sacketts turned to the Supreme Court for a second time after the San Francisco-based US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in August 2021 in favor of the federal government in its determination that the area did It was a wetland.
The law on how to define a wetland, of key interest to property developers and other commercial interests, has long been confused and was not resolved when the Supreme Court decided an earlier case on the subject. In 2006, four justices said the Clean Water Act covered wetlands with a “continuous surface connection” to a waterway, but there was no clear majority. Justice Anthony Kennedy, who provided the fifth vote in that 5-4 ruling, devised his own test, which said the law granted jurisdiction over wetlands with a “significant nexus” to a waterway.
Successive presidential administrations have tried to bring clarity to the law, with Democrats generally in favor of greater federal power and Republicans, backed by business interests, saying the Clean Water Act’s jurisdiction should be limited.
In Thursday’s ruling, the court rejected the significant nexus test and appeared to accept the approach taken by the four-judge block in the 2006 case.
“Sackett’s decision undoes half a century of progress generated by the Clean Water Act,” said Sam Sankar, an attorney with the environmental group Earthjustice. “Nearly 90 million acres of previously protected wetlands now face an existential threat from polluters and developers.”
The Biden administration finalized its own rule in December that largely reverted to the interpretation that existed before actions taken by the Obama and Trump administrations, though the new rule had already faced its own legal challenges. As a result of the Supreme Court ruling, the EPA will now have to go back to the drawing board.
