WASHINGTON – The Supreme Court is considering Wednesday whether Twitter can be sued for aiding and abetting the spread of militant Islamist ideology in a case involving a Jordanian citizen killed in a terrorist attack.
Relatives of Nawras Alassaf, who was murdered in Istanbul in 2017, filed a lawsuit alleging that Twitter, Google and Facebook were responsible for aiding and abetting the attack under a federal law called the Anti-Terror Law.
Wednesday’s argument is the second part of a doubleheader by Big Tech in the Supreme Court, where the justices on Tuesday fought a related case about whether Google-owned YouTube can be sued for similar conduct in connection with the murder of Nohemi González, an American. university student, in the 2015 Paris attacks carried out by the Islamic State terrorist group.
Unlike Tuesday’s case, Twitter’s argument does not refer to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, the legal shield that protects Internet companies from liability for content posted by users.
Instead, it focuses on whether such a claim can be brought under anti-terrorism law. Lower courts have not assessed whether Section 230 protects Twitter and the other companies in the case. Only Twitter formally appealed the appeals court ruling; facebook and google filed a brief support.
Alassaf was visiting Istanbul with his wife when he was one of 39 people killed by ISIS affiliate Abdulkadir Masharipov at the Reina nightclub. Masharipov had created a “martyrdom” video saying he was inspired by ISIS and wanted to die in a suicide attack. He evaded capture after the shots were fired, but was later arrested and convicted.
alassaf’s family it states that without the active assistance of Twitter, Facebook, and Google, the ISIS message and related recruitment efforts would not have spread as widely. It does not allege that Twitter has actively sought to help ISIS.
Twitter lawyers argue that it provides the same generic services to all its users and actively tries to prevent terrorists from using them. A ruling against the company could allow lawsuits against many entities that provide widely available goods or services, including humanitarian groups, lawyers say.
The Biden administration has filed a brief endorsing Twitter, saying the plaintiffs could not plausibly allege that the company knowingly provided assistance to ISIS.
A federal judge dismissed the suit, but the San Francisco-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit said in a 2021 ruling that the abetment claim could go forward. The family properly alleged that the companies had provided substantial assistance to ISIS, the court concluded.
In the related YouTube case, judges could avoid ruling on the scope of Section 230 immunity, a closely watched issue in the tech industry, by ruling in favor of Twitter in Wednesday’s case. That would get YouTube’s lawsuit dismissed regardless of whether the company is protected by Section 230.

