Roberts says building a fence around the Supreme Court is the “toughest decision” of his tenure

Roberts says building a fence around the Supreme Court is the “toughest decision” of his tenure

WASHINGTON (AP) — Chief Justice John Roberts’ most difficult decision in nearly two decades in office was to order a fence erected around the embattled Supreme Court last year after a leaked ruling striking down the right to abortion, he said Tuesday night.

Speaking before the American Law Institute, a legal group, he was defensive about the reputation of the court, amid questions about its legitimacy and calls for ethics reform.

“The most difficult decision I had to make was to put up fences and barricades around the Supreme Court. I had no choice but to go ahead and do it,” Roberts said.

The billboards were put up last May as part of heightened security measures following the leak and angry protests over the pending abortion ruling. The barricades added to the feeling that the court was a institution under siege.

Chief Justice Roberts says the Supreme Court is committed to ensuring ethical conduct
Chief Justice John Roberts speaks at the American Law Institute’s annual dinner in Washington on Tuesday. Jose Luis Magana / AP

The following month, the court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, struck down the Roe v. Wade’s 1973 bill establishing the constitutional right to abortion, though Roberts himself did not join the other five Conservatives who voted for it.

In her time on the court, Roberts has been a key figure in cases that restricted voting rights, expanded gun rights, and defended the Obamacare health care law,

In his brief speech Tuesday, he lamented public criticism of the judiciary, including protests outside judges’ homes, and appeared to take issue with Congressional ethics reform legislation for the court in the wake of the stories. recent reports on Conservative Justice Clarence Thomas.

But Roberts, noting that the legislation was not necessary, also said he thought the court could make its own reforms and hold itself to the highest standards so that a showdown with Congress would not be necessary.

“I want to assure people that I am committed to making sure that we as a court hold ourselves to the highest standards of conduct. We continue to look at the things we can do to give practical effect to that commitment,” he said.

Lawmakers have introduced legislation that would require judges to adhere to a code of ethics similar to that required of other federal judges. Roberts declined an invitation to testify on the issue, and the nine justices signed a statement of ethical principles that was widely criticized by legal experts and Democrats alike.

Some legal experts have suggested that any effort by Congress to legislate on ethics would unconstitutionally infringe on the Supreme Court’s status as a separate branch of government, although the court has followed similar steps in the past.

Roberts added that the justices remain on good terms and said that “no angry voice has ever been raised” in private meetings.

Liberal judge Elena Kagan introduced Roberts at the event, during which she received an award, praising her ability to write convincingly on complex legal issues. But she added, in a reference to divisions on the pitch, there are so many other issues that “I’m pulling my hair out” over.

The court is about to head into the home stretch of its current term, which ends at the end of June. Important rulings will be issued in the coming weeks on a number of issues, including affirmative action on college admissions and the Biden administration’s offer to forgive student loan debt.

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like