Nikki Haley’s campaign opened with a call for race. Some American Indians say it won’t work.

Nikki Haley’s campaign opened with a call for race.  Some American Indians say it won’t work.

Former South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley has long rejected the idea that the United States is a racist country. But when it came time to announce his run for the 2024 presidency on Tuesday, he began by sharing his identity and a memory of his hometown.

“The train tracks divided the city by race,” he said of Bamberg, South Carolina. “I was the proud daughter of Indian immigrants. Neither black nor white, I was different”.

Haley’s announcement makes her the first Republican opponent of former President Donald Trump, in whose administration she spent two years as ambassador to the United Nations.

But if Haley, born Nimrata Randhawa to Punjabi Sikh parents, is trying to make her way among Indian-Americans, experts say it’s not working.

She doesn’t represent the community, said Varun Nikore, executive director of AAPI Victory Alliance, a nonprofit organization that represents Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders. In fact, Nikore said, “there are a multitude of issues where she and the GOP are diametrically opposed to where AAPI is.”

Haley did not respond to NBC News’ request for comment.

Some South Asians say Haley’s intermittent acknowledgment of her ethnicity is a familiar routine. Nikore, who has followed Haley’s career from the beginning, says using her racial identity often goes hand-in-hand with perpetuating the model minority myth, taking anti-immigration stances and opposing the comprehensive race education in the usa

“I think people can see through it much better now than ever before,” Nikore said. “For her to try to talk about her immigrant background, I think she will fail.”

But as Asian Americans become more politically active, the 2024 presidential candidates will generally find their way, he said.

“Our level of political sophistication has grown by leaps and bounds,” Nikore said. “And that shows up in the participation rates and the level of civic engagement at the local level all the way to the top.”

According to the 2022 Asian American Voter Pollonly 15 percent of Indians American voters are decidedly Republican. Fifty-six percent are Democrats and 19 percent are independents. Nikore says she sees Haley’s appeal to some older first-generation Indian Americans, but doesn’t envision the community as a whole getting behind her.

A Democratic and South Asian commentator agreed. “I think I speak for a lot of people when I say that Nikki Haley’s values ​​are not the values ​​of the American Indian community,” Kaivan Shroff tweeted. “He is a deeply cynical and unkind person. His candidacy is not the kind of representation we should celebrate.”

An overwhelmingly Democratic constituency with a large immigrant population, Asian Americans are concerned about racism, access to health care, gun control and the environment, according to the 2022 survey. Indian Americans prioritize gun control more than any other ethnic group, and it’s a political position Haley has strongly opposed.

“These are areas where the Republican Party and conservatives have placed their bets on the future of their movement: guns and reproductive rights,” Nikore said. “They are going to find, to their demise, that they are on the wrong side of today and on the wrong side of history.”

Neil Makhija, executive director of the voter mobilization nonprofit Indian American Impact, said the Biden administration had engaged South Asian American voters in a way Republicans never have. On Haley’s presidential bid, he said, “I think it will be hard for Republicans to make a dent in our community’s support unless they turn the tide on the nativism and xenophobia that Trump unleashed.”

Nikore says Haley cannot separate herself from the racist, Islamophobic and anti-immigrant stances of the modern Republican Party. As ambassador to the UN, Haley defended Trump’s executive order banning travel to the US from some Muslim-majority nations in 2017, saying: “It’s not a Muslim ban.”

Using scaremongering sentiment to scapegoat immigrants has become the bedrock of conservatism, Nikore said, adding that Haley’s refusal to oppose it while promoting her own background will alienate voters.

“If they do not repudiate the most extremist elements of their own party and denounce people about their white supremacist and racist words and actions, you are in fact complicit,” he said. “She made decisions that I think she will have to live with for the rest of her political career.”

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like