At first, the Montana-based creators of TikTok weren’t concerned about a possible ban on the app in the state. But when Gov. Greg Gianforte signed a bill restricting downloads of the immensely popular social media app, fear and frustration set in.
“It feels like we are one step closer to losing our freedom and the freedom that Montanans hold dear,” said Spencre McGowan, a Butte-based content creator who has more than 109,000 followers.
She is among the countless content creators in the state who will be affected when the bill, SB 419, takes effect in January 2024. The legislation makes it illegal for app stores to give users the option to download TikTok and for the company to operate within the state. Violations of a ban include any time a user is offered the ability to download the app. Each violation could carry a $10,000 fine. The execution would be handled by the Montana Department of Justice.
The ban is already facing a legal battle: On Wednesday, a group of five TikTokers sued the state, arguing that the law is an unconstitutional violation of free speech rights.
For creators like McGowan, who earn between $350 and $1,100 from their sponsored posts, the app has been a way out of the water financially.
While McGowan, author of the “Forest + Home” cookbook, has a part-time job creating content for kelp company Daybreak Seaweed, TikTok is where she creates handcrafted content and earns a decent income.
“When I started getting paid and brands kept reaching out to me for my work as an herbalist, artist and cook, I felt really special and meaningful,” she said. “And finances are such a useful addition to my current paycheck.”
Fear that freedoms will be stripped
The Montana ban cites TikTok owner, China-based ByteDance, as responsible for banning the platform.
“The Chinese Communist Party using TikTok to spy on Americans, violate their privacy and collect their personal, private and sensitive information is well documented,” Gianforte said in a press release, calling the law “the most decisive action of any state”. .”
More than half of US states and the federal government have banned TikTok on government-owned devices, according to The Associated Press.
TikTok has tried to persuade US officials that they can address security concerns and meet the proposed level of scrutiny. TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew told Congress in March that 150 million people in the US are regular users of the app, whose popularity has skyrocketed in recent years.
Montana’s blanket ban prevents our customers, and all Montanans, from engaging in protected speech
-Ambika Kumar, lead attorney for the plaintiffs in the Montana lawsuit
The creators of TikTok also held a press conference in Washington, DC in March after it was reported that the Biden administration was considering a nationwide ban on the app unless its owners sold their shares.
This week, five Montana-based TikTok content creators—Samantha Alario, Heather DiRocco, Carly Ann Goddard, Alice Held, and Dale Stout—submitted a suit against the state, alleging that the ban attempts to suppress speech and “exercises a power over national security that Montana does not have.”
Plaintiffs have used the app to help promote their businesses, connect with military veterans, share videos about ranch life and post humorous sketches.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately make them available for comment.
“Montana’s blanket ban prevents our clients, and all Montanans, from engaging in protected speech,” said Ambika Kumar, lead attorney for the plaintiffs in the Montana lawsuit. Kumar previously won a mandate in 2020, when then-President Donald Trump tried to ban TikTok.
“We are determined to see this wrong and invalid law imposed permanently,” Kumar said.
In response to the lawsuit, Emily Flower, a spokeswoman for the Montana Department of Justice, said: “We expected a legal challenge and we are fully prepared to uphold the law.”
McGowan said he feels the TikTok ban is another blow to the freedoms of Montanans, citing the recent abortion ban after 15 weeks as another act that increases your anxiety. (Montana’s abortion ban has been temporarily blocked by a judge.) He also pointed to the state’s treatment of transgender people as a reason for his growing unease.
Although McGowan doesn’t have children yet, she said these recent legislative changes have made her hesitant about raising a family in Montana.
“Realistically, if trans healthcare is denied, if pregnant people aren’t treated as equals, and if we’re not allowed to download an app… I told my husband I don’t want to raise our children in a state that would allow that”.
Montana without TikTok: ‘An absolute shame’
Montana may not be considered a bustling hub for creators and influencers, but it’s still home to many who rely on the app to earn an income and connect with the rest of the world.
Among the most famous content creators living in Montana is Hank Green, a pillar of internet culture. Upon learning of the ban, Green responded by tweeting an angry emoji. Green did not respond to a request for comment.
Country singer Jonah Prill, a Billings native, said TikTok has been a crucial component in building his fan base. Prill, who has more than 809,000 followers, called it “the most useful, creative and best tool for me and my colleagues.”
“This is an incredible time that this bill has been introduced because I am currently in the middle of launching a song, and my most important tool is TikTok,” Prill said.
Although Prill recently moved to Nashville for her music career, she said TikTok continues to be an effective tool for connecting with her fans in Montana and around the world, especially ahead of the release of her upcoming song “All That Pretty.”
Prill said he hopes Montana residents don’t lose access to an app that he believes has tremendous power for both businesses and individuals looking to connect with one another.
“Honestly, we don’t have internet or cell reception in most of the state,” Prill joked. “However, it would be an absolute shame if the rest of the world or even someone from a neighboring state couldn’t necessarily have access to the beauty of the place and the incredible people of Montana.”

