Evangelisto Ramos walked out of a New Orleans courthouse and walked away from a life sentence accompanying a 10-2 jury conviction, thanks in large part to the landmark US Supreme Court decision that bears his name. .
Ramos vs. Louisiana banned convictions by unanimous juries as unconstitutional, and the justices in a 6-3 majority recognized the practice as a holdover from racism from the era of “Jim Crow” laws enforcing racial segregation.
The 2020 ruling meant a new trial for Ramos, who was acquitted in March, this time by a unanimous jury, after defense attorneys highlighted weaknesses in the investigation that led to his prosecution.
“I knew my case was important because a lot of people were going to get their freedom back,” Ramos, a black immigrant from Honduras, told The Associated Press, answering questions by email about his time in prison and his search for a new trial.
But the prospects for freedom remain murky for hundreds of people convicted by 10-2 or 11-1 jury votes whose appeals were exhausted before the Ramos case was decided. The advocacy group Promise of Justice Initiative estimates that there are more than 1,500 of those people locked up in Louisiana.
In Oregon, the only other state that allowed non-unanimous verdicts for convictions before the Ramos case, the state Supreme Court granted new trials. But the US Supreme Court and the Louisiana Supreme Court rejected arguments to apply the ruling retroactively.
Louisiana advocates have also turned to the Legislature in recent years. But the latest potential remedy has stalled in the House and appears dead after House representatives voted 50-38 against the measure on Thursday. Supporters are unlikely to be able to revive the bill with two weeks left in the legislative session.
The proposal drew criticism from some prosecutors who did not want to re-examine old cases, as well as advocates for the people it was supposed to benefit.
Instead of retroactively granting new trials, the legislation would establish a commission of three retired state appellate or Supreme Court judges empowered to decide whether the verdict “resulted in judicial error” and whether probation is warranted.
Supporters of the bill by Rep. Randal Gaines, a LaPlace Democrat, present it as a compromise. Prosecutors had argued that the mandatory new trials would strain the judicial system, renew the emotional pain of crime victims and their families, and overwhelm prosecutors with years of evidence and, in some cases, witnesses who have died or not been found. can find.
Even the compromise failed to convince some state prosecutors, according to Loren Lampert, director of the Louisiana District Attorneys Association, which was officially neutral on the bill. Meanwhile, criminal justice advocates were not happy about the lack of a path to exoneration from the compromise measure.
“It has to be a real relief — to be released from being found guilty,” said Hardell Ward, a lawyer with the Promise Justice Initiative whose client case led to a state high court ruling that barred older, exhausted convictions from appeals from the prohibition of non-unanimous verdicts.
Ramos was arrested in 2014 and tried on a second-degree murder charge for the stabbing death of a woman found in a trash can in front of his home. All but two of the jurors found him guilty in 2016. Defense attorneys for the retrial noted that DNA from two people, neither of them Ramos, was found under the victim’s fingernails. No blood was recovered from the floor of Ramos’s apartment, where prosecutors argued that she was murdered.
“The importance of what this verdict says about how deeply problematic these broken jurors were cannot be overstated,” said Sarah Chervinsky, one of Ramos’s trial attorneys.
Non-unanimous jury policies were based on post-Civil War policy and designed to make it easier to convict black defendants, even with one or two black juries.
In 2018, Louisiana voters barred non-unanimous verdicts for crimes committed after January 1, 2019. The vote followed a series of Pulitzer Prize-winning stories in The Advocate looking at the law’s racist origins and racial disparities. in the verdicts.
Ramos’s 2020 decision affected active cases even for crimes committed before 2019. But progress stalled when higher courts refused to make Ramos’s decision retroactive.
Some prosecutors have been tasked with reviewing cases involving Jim Crow verdicts.
Jason Williams established a civil rights division when he took over the New Orleans district attorney’s office in 2021 on a platform of reform. His office says more than 100 of the estimated 230 cases have been reviewed. Cases against 10 wrongfully convicted people have been dismissed and dozens of sentences or charges have been reduced.
It’s unclear how many verdicts have come out differently after Ramos. The Louisiana District Attorneys Association is not compiling those statistics, Lampert said in an email.
New trials do not always lead to new verdicts. A Jefferson Parish jury unanimously convicted a man of second-degree murder whose 2018 unanimous conviction had been overturned. Jefferson prosecutors obtained a similar result in a new trial last August.
But a new trial that requires a unanimous verdict may mean that a case with a margin of doubt is scrutinized further, Chervinsky said.
“It’s not a technicality, it’s not an insignificant difference, when the prosecutor has to convince all 12 people to accept a unanimous verdict,” Chervinsky said. “That encourages more vigorous debate and discussion. It requires them to really take into account all possible reasonable doubt in the case in a way that I think jurors can ignore if they’re allowed to ignore the voices of two people in that room.”

