Lawyers spar on John Eastman’s disbarment case for trying to keep Trump in power

Lawyers spar on John Eastman’s disbarment case for trying to keep Trump in power

LOS ANGELES — An attorney representing attorney John Eastman, the architect of a legal strategy aimed at keeping former President Donald Trump in power after the 2020 election, highlighted legal debates Wednesday surrounding the counting of electoral votes in Eastman’s council’s defense of the former president that he could get him disbarred.

Eastman, a former dean of the law school, faces 11 disciplinary charges in California State Bar Court in the wake of his development of a dubious legal strategy aimed at getting then-Vice President Mike Pence to interfere with President Joe Biden’s certification of victory.

Prosecutors have described Eastman as a rogue lawyer and Trump enabler who fabricated an unsubstantiated theory and made false claims of fraud in hopes of overturning the election results.

On the second day of the proceedings, defense attorney Randall A. Miller highlighted scholarly debates about the scope of the vice president’s authority in the electoral process, in an apparent attempt to counter the argument that Eastman was making unsubstantiated claims in an attempt to last minute to save the Trump presidency.

Among his points, Miller pointed to a December 8, 2020 memo written by Pence’s attorney at the time, Gregory Jacob, who testified for much of the day. In the memo, Jacob tells Pence that there is disagreement over whether Pence’s role is ministerial or whether the vice president can “play a decisive role in resolving objections to electoral votes on their merits.”

However, Pence ultimately concluded that his role was largely ceremonial and that he did not have the authority to discard the electoral votes that would make Democrat Joe Biden the next president, despite public pressure from Trump and legal arguments from Eastman. .

In a January 5 memo, Jacob argued that Eastman’s advice to delay the vote count would likely lose in court and could result in a showdown in Congress.

Earlier in the one-day hearing, prosecutors who called Jacob as a witness walked him through his interactions with Eastman, largely echoing what Jacob told the House committee on Jan. 6 during his investigation into the 2021 Capitol insurrection.

Eastman’s assertions at different times that the vice president should, and had the authority to, disallow electors or delay proceedings did not square with the Constitution or federal law, Jacob testified.

“No vice president in the entire history of our country had ever asserted, made a public statement, that he had the authority” to reject electoral ballot certificates, Jacob said.

To Pence, “it didn’t make any constitutional sense … for the framers of our Constitution to give authority to reject voters in an individual,” he added.

Miller previously argued that Eastman never intended to steal the election, but was instead considering ways to delay the electoral vote count so that states could investigate allegations of voting irregularities. Trump’s fraud allegations were roundly rejected by the courts, including Republican-appointed judges.

Prosecutors have said Eastman continued his efforts to undermine the election even after state and federal officials publicly rejected claims of fraud by Trump allies.

“All of his misconduct was done for a single purpose: to obstruct the voter count on January 6 and prevent Vice President Pence from certifying Joe Biden as the winner of the election,” Duncan Carling of the office of lead trial attorney, who is seeking the disbarment of Eastman, he said in proceedings Tuesday. “He was fully aware in real time that his plan was damaging the nation.”

The process is expected to take at least eight days. The California State Bar Association is a regulatory agency and the only judicial system in the US dedicated to the discipline of lawyers.

It may take weeks or months before a decision is made.

Once the proceeding is complete, the State Bar Court has 90 days to render its decision, which is a recommendation that then goes to the California Supreme Court.

The State Bar Association alleges that Eastman violated California’s business and professions code by making false and misleading statements that constitute acts of “moral turpitude, dishonesty, and corruption,” and in doing so, “breached this duty in furtherance of an intent to to usurp the will of the American people and overturn the results of the election for the highest office in the country: an unprecedented and heinous attack on our democracy.”

Eastman was dean of the Chapman University School of Law from 2007 to 2010. He was a professor at the school when he retired in 2021.

Eastman has been a member of the California Bar Association since 1997, according to his website. She was a law clerk to US Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and a founding director of the Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence, a law firm affiliated with the Claremont Institute. He ran for California attorney general in 2010 and finished second in the Republican primary.

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like