How the train derailment in East Palestine fueled fear on TikTok

How the train derailment in East Palestine fueled fear on TikTok

He train derailment in eastern Palestine, Ohio, has turned TikTok into a hotbed for misinformation and conspiracy theories, leading people beyond the region to worry about the potential repercussions of the chemical release.

TikTok videos warning of acid rain across the country have permeated the platform. Some users, from the East Coast to Southern California, claim they smelled “chemical” odors, while others questioned whether the derailment was a “distraction” to divert public attention from other conspiracies. Dozens of videos of dust-like residue, which some users say appeared on their cars after it rained, have gone viral.

“What is so powerful about this particular incident is that it taps into so many grievances and so many narratives that it seems to be running the ideological spectrum in terms of who it is bringing into the fold,” said researcher Meghan Conroy. fellow studying Internet culture and extremism with the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensics Investigation Laboratory.

The aftermath of the trail derailment has concerned environmentalists, rural Americans who already feel “forgotten,” and those who mistrust the government. Responses from public officials have been confusing, inappropriate or slow for some people, creating the perfect conditions for misinformation to spread on TikTok, a platform many people have turned to for updates.

The 150-car train containing vinyl chloride, a highly flammable and toxic chemical, derailed in eastern Palestine on February 3. To prevent an explosion, the Norfolk Southern Railway executed a controlled release of vinyl chloride on February 6 and ordered residents to evacuate because the vapors can be deadly if inhaled.

Two days after the launch, Ohio officials informed residents that they could back home. The Environmental Protection Agency found no “excesses in residential air quality standards” in the 533 local homes it tested. from February 19. Still, nearby residents complained of suspicious-looking water and health issues after the derailment, with some taking to TikTok to voice their concerns.

This photo taken with a drone shows parts of a Norfolk and Southern freight train that derailed Friday night in East Palestine, Ohio, still ablaze at noon on Saturday, February 4, 2023.
Parts of a Norfolk Southern freight train that derailed in East Palestine, Ohio, catching fire on February 4.File Gene J. Puskar / AP

“There certainly is a difference in how people listen to what the government tells them and how that translates into their own lives,” said Rachel Dowty Beech, a tenured professor in the University of New Haven’s emergency management program.

He added that part of the communication problem between the public and government officials lies in the differences in the “definitions of safety formed by chemists and experts, and the definitions of the people who see the effects.” When government guarantees of security feel at odds with the experiences of residents on the ground, people feel distrustful and frustrated.

“If the local community doesn’t trust the government, they are more likely to find their own explanations among themselves than to go to a scientific authority,” Dowty Beech said.

The disaster in Ohio also tapped into some lingering fears that surfaced at the start of the pandemic. She said that since the start of the pandemic, many people have been concerned about local catastrophes spreading to wider areas.

TikTok users have claimed that acid rain has made its way from Ohio to several states on the East Coast, using the smell in the air, the oily film on the water, and the residue on their cars as “evidence.” However, Dowty Beech said that hydrochloric acid, which is the byproduct of burning vinyl chloride, is not normally absorbed by the air stream or generates acid rain. EPA state that acid rain occurs when sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides are released into the atmosphere, typically from the burning of fossil fuels.

The New York Department of Environmental Conservation told NBC News that it has not detected an increase in acidity from rain in the state, despite some claims on TikTok in recent days.

“The air mass that passed over the Ohio train derailment and fire has long since passed over New York,” an agency representative said.

Conroy said inadequate communication from public officials has created a “data vacuum” that many “bad faith actors are more than willing to fill.” Conspiracy theories involving public health and environmental disasters are not new, he said: Unsubstantiated rumors of “chemtrails,” fluoridated water and nuclear power continue to proliferate online despite overwhelming evidence proving they are false.

“There is no substantive understanding that the common person has where they can easily debunk these things, or even understand things when they have been debunked,” he said. “And so, there were already large groups of people who are prepared to believe another conspiracy theory about yet another incident that leverages these existing conspiracy theories in a really strong way.”

There is this type of conspiracy that dominates much of the American imagination and requires absolutely no proof.

— Yotam Ophir, assistant professor of communication at the University at Buffalo

Many conspiracy theories began and spread in more marginal spaces, such as closed Facebook groups or 4chan. TikTok is in a unique position to bring theories, even if they are completely unfounded, to a wider audience by continuing to promote highly engaging content.

Yotam Ophir, an assistant professor of communication at the University at Buffalo and an expert on health, science and political misinformation, said the newest conspiracy theories feed on attention, not research. Decades ago, conspiracy theorists meticulously collected and analyzed whatever evidence they could find to try to explain the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, he said, and even if they were wrong, “at least they were looking for evidence.”

He compared it to a recent TikTok that quoted the 2022 Netflix Movie “White Noise”, an absurd comedy-drama about a similar train derailment, as “evidence” that the incident was “planned”. The video featured text overlaid on clips of someone driving in the rain and used a sound from TikTok that has been used in horror and true crime content.

“There are these types of conspiracies that dominate much of the American imagination and require absolutely no evidence,” Ophir said. “The question is why are social networks such a useful vehicle to spread it, and the answer is that these videos are interesting. And then we come to the algorithms that decide what post we’re going to see on social by prioritizing engagement, not necessarily the weight of evidence that people bring to the table or factuality or anything like that.”

He also questioned whether TikTok users who post conspiracy theory content are actually interested in finding “hidden realities” or if they are simply motivated to go viral. Wilder theories tend to be more attractive, she said, which is highly rewarded on social media. He pointed out that there have been conspiracies that have been proven true, such as the Iran Contra case and the Watergate scandal.

“They were discovered by academics, journalists, people working in professions who have the tools, the integrity and the systematic support to identify stories like that,” Ophir said. “They can’t and will never be revealed by a guy with an iPhone in California.”

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like