A divided federal appeals court Tuesday upheld the constitutionality of a new admissions policy at an elite public high school in Virginia that critics say discriminates against highly qualified Asian-Americans.
2-1 ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in Richmond vacates a ruling last year from a federal judge who found the Fairfax County School Board engaged in unconscionable “racial balancing” when it reviewed the admissions policy at Thomas Jefferson High School of Science and Technology.
The school is frequently cited among the best in the nation, and parents compete and prepare for years to get their children admitted. But for decades, black and Hispanic students have been woefully underrepresented, while Asian Americans made up more than 70% of the student body.
In 2020, the school board significantly revamped the admissions process, eliminating a standardized test that had been a linchpin in favor of a system that reserved an equal number of Thomas Jefferson seats at each of the county’s middle schools, among other changes. . The process does not take race into account. It gives weight in favor of applicants who are economically disadvantaged or who are still learning English.
The first freshman class admitted under the new rules saw a significantly different racial makeup. black students increased from 1% to 7%; Hispanic representation increased from 3% to 11%. Asian American representation decreased from 73% to 54%.
Critics of the new policy say it discriminates against Asian-American applicants who would have been granted admission if academic merit were the only criteria, and that efforts to increase Black and Hispanic representation necessarily come at the expense of Asian Americans.
But Tuesday’s majority opinion by Judge Robert King said the school board had a legitimate interest in increasing diversity in the school and misrepresenting those efforts as discrimination against Asian Americans “simply goes against common sense.”
Judge Allison Jones Rushing dissented.
“The Policy reduced enrollment offers to Asian students at TJ by 26% while increasing enrollment for all other racial groups. This was not an accident. The Board intended to alter the racial makeup of the school in exactly this way,” she wrote.
Rushing said the policy is neutral on its face, but the debate surrounding its implementation reflected a clear desire for racial balance. He criticized his colleagues for refusing to “look beyond the neutral veneer of Politics.”
Tuesday’s ruling comes as US Supreme Court weighs pivotal case challenging whether Harvard University and the University of North Carolina should be allowed to account for race in their admissions policies.

