The Marine Corps veteran who was seen on video subjecting Jordan Neely to fatal strangulation on a New York City subway was arraigned Friday on a second-degree manslaughter charge that Neely’s family suggested it was too lenient.
“Is that enough for someone who strangled someone on the train and took their own life?” asked attorney Lennon Edwards at a news conference Friday afternoon, hours after Daniel Penny turned himself in at the 5th Precinct police station in Manhattan.
Edwards said Neely’s family wanted Penny charged with murder because she could have chosen any other technique, but “she intentionally chose a technique designed to cut through the air.”
“That is a choice he made and he made it intentionally. So we believe that the conviction should be for murder because that is intentional,” he told reporters.
Officials have not said how they reached an agreement on the manslaughter charge.
Thomas Kenniff, Penny’s attorney, said Friday that his client voluntarily turned himself in shortly after 8 am ET “with the kind of dignity and integrity that is characteristic of his history of service to this grateful nation.”
Penny, 24, left the police station in handcuffs and was escorted to a waiting car that took him to the Manhattan criminal courthouse. He did not respond to questions from reporters.
Penny entered the courthouse surrounded by detectives and dressed in a gray suit, white shirt and a mask.
During the process, the judge asked him if he was waiving extradition and he said “yes”.
Bail was set at $100,000 during his arraignment. Penny put up $6,000 and her parents guaranteed full bail.
As he left, he was surrounded by his defense team and detectives, and several people came up to shake his hand.

Cell phone video partially captured the May 1 incident on a northbound F train. showed penny on the ground holding Neely, 30, in a chokehold after an altercation.
Neely was unconscious when officers arrived and pronounced him dead at the hospital, police said. The city medical examiner’s office said he died of “neck compression (strangulation)” and that the manner was a homicide.
Penny was briefly detained after the incident and released.
Juan Alberto Vázquez, a witness who filmed the cell phone footage, said NBC New York that Neely got on the train and “started making a kind of aggressive speech, saying he was hungry, he was thirsty, he didn’t care, he didn’t care about going to jail, he didn’t care about that he gets a big life sentence ”. Neely was homeless and was described as a subway busker who performed dance routines dressed as Michael Jackson.
Neely was strangled for about 15 minutes, Vazquez said. Video showed two other subway passengers appearing to help restrain him.
Penny’s lawyers also said that Neely was “aggressively threatening” the passengers and that Penny never intended to harm her. Neely’s family, however, rejected that version.
“This is an assassination of character and a clear example of why he believed he had the right to take Jordan’s life,” his lawyers previously said.
On Friday, attorney Donte Mills questioned why no one on the train helped Neely, who said she suffered from mental illness as a result of her mother’s murder.
“Nobody on that train asked Jordan, ‘What’s up? How can I help you?’ Instead he was strangled to death,” he said. “Don’t take a loved one from someone because they are in a bad place.”
A police spokesperson said multiple 911 calls were received about a physical fight and that Neely and Penny were involved in a “verbal dispute” that “developed into a physical altercation.”
“During the physical struggle between the two men, the 30-year-old man lost consciousness,” the spokesperson said earlier.
Neely’s death sparked a national debate, with people denouncing vigilantism and some politicians demanding that officials do more to address homelessness, mental health and violence on the subways.
In a statement Friday, the Rev. Al Sharpton urged the justice system to send “a strong and clear message that vigilantism has never been acceptable.”
“Being homeless or black or having a mental health episode should not be a death sentence,” he said, calling the charges against Penny “the first step in justice.”
Sharpton, the host of MSNBC’s “PoliticsNation,” is expected to deliver the eulogy at Neely’s funeral next Friday in Harlem.
Penny’s next court date is scheduled for July 17.
jonathan dienst, andres siff, marc santia and Brittany Kubicko contributed.



