Chronically Online Third Culture Is Redefining Asian America

Chronically Online Third Culture Is Redefining Asian America

It’s a new era in Asia America, and the TikTok generation is running it.

Scroll through your For You page a few times and you’ll easily come across various Asian “It Girls” who draw millions of views showcasing ancient beauty rituals. Swipe a little further up and you might find home cooks packing bento boxes or musicians mixing ’70s Bollywood tunes with viral pop hits.

The panic of opening an ethnic lunch box in a crowded cafeteria is dead to them. He has been traded for videos of his moms’ recipes narrated by artificial intelligence. The ridicule suffered by expressive classical dances are in the rear view mirror. Now they are making money doing the same dances on the Internet.

What was once a burning thirst for representation has been quenched, even drowned, on the Internet, the young people said. And for a generation of Asian-Americans raised on social media, whose culture has always been ill-defined, stereotyped, starred, pushed to the sidelines, and seen in the shadow of whiteness, becoming their own medium means putting up a heritage that ever tried to bury in full screen.

“They’re moving through the world in a way that they don’t feel like they have to explain themselves,” said Christine Bacareza Balance, director of Cornell University’s department of Asian American studies. “There’s a joy in being Asian-American.”

They move through the world in a way that they don’t feel like they have to explain themselves.”

— Christine Bacareza Balance, professor at Cornell University

Existing in two worlds, often in conflict with each other, is not a new concept, experts said. But there’s something different about the way those in the internet generation navigate life. Social media has freed them in many ways from the rigid standards of white society; they have created their own spaces, their own stars, and their own expectations of what their lives could be like.

It’s not where your parents came from; nor does it resemble the life of his white companions. What seemed like a childhood of collective identity crisis has finally turned into quiet confidence, and many in Generation Z say they are now comfortable, even thriving, with what they have found in between.

exposure changes everything

Ten years ago, when changing channels or even browsing the YouTube home page, Asian-American kids had a hard time finding a famous face or two from the community. Now on TikTok, a dozen can easily go through in a few minutes.

Unlike pre-2000s media that had few Asian-American voices, the Internet generation offered a free and instant participation alternative.

Digital communities began to form, giving birth to new kinds of stars. Facebook pages like Subtle Asian Traits made room for mutual recognition; high school students who were the only Asians in their cities could now log in and talk to thousands of people. Filmmakers like Wong Fu Productions, which has made Asian-focused short films, brought their work to YouTube.

Suddenly, the bar for representation was much lower.

“There were no goalkeepers anymore. You no longer had to wait for Hollywood to give you the green light,” Balance said.

Thus was born the child of the chronically online third culture. And YouTube ushered in an era of Asian-American celebrities speaking directly to them, in real time. They based their content on the experience of dealing with foreign parents, the disconnect they had with their white peers, the unique challenges of dating as a first generation.

“They really captured how they were feeling and the things they were experiencing in a way that the mainstream media didn’t,” Balance said.

Twitter in its early days also lent itself to building communities, said Aaron Yin, 28, a comedian and content creator who co-hosts the “Politically Asian” podcast.

“There were group chats, not just for Asian people, but also for anyone who wasn’t white on Twitter, because sometimes Twitter felt very white,” he said. “That helped me develop my race awareness a little bit more.”

Young Gen Zers who became adults long after that era probably can’t remember a time when Asian social media figures weren’t around, Balance said. So when TikTok blew up, they didn’t hesitate to take on that role.

“When TikTok came along, it completely changed everything,” said Malvika Sheth, a 24-year-old Gujarati American influencer who has earned more than 100,000 followers on Instagram for her fashion content. Millions of people have watched her TikTok videos of her day-to-day outfits, often featuring jewelry or traditional Indian fabrics.

With no more than a search, fantastic and relatable people of color can appear on your For You page by the dozens: Asian people from every community and ethnicity who live every lifestyle imaginable and make a name for themselves doing so.

Storytellers, comedians and musicians weave culture into their content in ways that feel unspoken and natural, the youth said. There are Asians who show off their daily routines in Los Angeles and New York and others who live out fantasies in the woods.

“It’s about range,” Balance said. “Stories that are told, emotions that are expressed. What is different for Generation Z is that there is a kind of diversity and heterogeneity in the stories that are told.

Yin said that we are beyond the point of representation itself, especially if that representation is achieved by leaning towards a white system.

He uses his platforms to mock what he sees as the kind of misrepresentation; created a list of “8 Asian American Pioneers Who Made Things Worse” which included designer Alexander Wang and Ajit PaiFormer Chairman of the Federal Communications Commission.

“Especially with the younger people that I talk to, there really isn’t that theme of ‘Oh, I want to see someone who looks like me,’” she said. “To be honest, when I hear that sentence, I think the person might be over 35 years old.”

Young Asian-Americans know how to create the kind of representation they want, on their own terms, and they know that their culture can be a tool to get them there, not a hindrance.

“I think just the short video format helped me express myself a lot more,” Sheth said. “Seeing other brown people doing amazing things really helped me say to myself, ‘Yes, you are worthy of trying these great things.'”

And seeing the cool Asian kids on TikTok embracing their roots in public has ushered in a homecoming for many Gen Zers on the app.

Culture panic at acceptance

A passerby walking down the hallway from Naomi Namboodiripad’s bedroom can hear the familiar sound of the latest hip-hop thumping behind her door. But inside, 21-year-old Namboodiripad, a TikTok celebrity, is gearing up for an all-out Bharatanatyam dance performance.

Dressed from head to toe in an ornate South Indian blouse and skirt, she films herself doing ancient traditional steps to the beat of Beyoncé and Apollo Fresh. The video she is recording will reach an audience of 350,000. Views and likes often reach millions.

“I would be surprised when I was younger,” said Namboodiripad, a junior at Columbia University.

Growing up in her white suburb, she never felt the need to hide her culture. But he remembers being teased by his white classmates once when he performed Bharatanatyam for them. He never felt there was a real forum to display what he learned in the dance style, characterized by dramatic facial expressions, wide eyes, and hand movements.

“I felt like I was a bit trapped,” she said. “I wanted to embrace my Indian culture, but I had no one to do it with outside of my family.”

Balance said that Asian culture in Western art too often comes with an asterisk. Foods, communities, cultures, and practices are explained in painful detail for a white consumer base. Gen Z is over it.

“TikTok is really bringing all these cultures that don’t know each other together, and we’re learning without having to be spoon-fed,” Namboodiripad said. “Like, ‘Oh, this means this, that means that.’ None of that needs to be said.”

TikTok is really bringing all these cultures that don’t know each other together, and we’re learning without having to be spoon-fed a baby.”

— Naomi Namboodiripad, 21, Influential

For Sheth, that means not forcing himself in any direction. In her fashion content, she often struggles with whether she should lean more towards her Indian identity. But ultimately, he wants her work to feel authentic to her.

“From college, from dance, from all these experiences, when I started creating content online, I always knew that I wanted to mix my culture in the most natural way,” she said. “Like, I don’t wear Indian clothes every day. But if I go to a casual place and feel like wearing a jhumki, I can do it.”

Some say they have felt a similar transition: the cultural panic of childhood has turned into a gentle drift. Existing in the middle is becoming easier.

Sheth sees the third culture not just as a set of practices or traits, but as an unpacking and reconstruction of both cultures from which it came.

As her parents’ eldest daughter, for example, she sees the burden that often falls on the shoulders of Indian women in their family units. In the third culture, a balance can be struck between that lifestyle and American individualism, she said. She pursues her own life, but still helps her family and calls her mother several times a day.

“Sometimes it’s really asking me and telling me not to feel guilty when I want to do things for myself,” she said.

Yin has turned her attention to Chinatown communities in New York City, making TikTok videos that satirise exploitation by powerful landlords and city officials. He sees comedy as a way to reach young people and hopefully motivate them to take action in the real world.

He takes his word to the streets, picketing, organizing and protesting the issues he talks about on TikTok and on his podcast.

Young Asian creators don’t care if what they’re doing is niche, they said. If they care, they’ll post it to the world, and if others want to be a part of it, they’ll join in too.

“I feel like 60% anger every day and then 20% hope and 20% sadness,” he said. “But I don’t feel angry in a desperate way. More in a ‘I don’t want to give up’ kind of way.”

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like