Camilla swaps the Kohinoor diamond for another controversial stone in her coronation crown

Camilla swaps the Kohinoor diamond for another controversial stone in her coronation crown

After much speculation, Camilla, the queen consort, will not wear the controversial Kohinoor diamond which critics say was looted under British rule, but some see the decision as an empty gesture.

The Royal Family Announced this week that Queen Mary’s crown, which featured a replica of the Kohinoor diamond, would be restored without the stone ahead of King Charles III’s coronation.

Instead, the crown will include the Cullinan III, IV and V diamonds as a tribute to Queen Elizabeth II. The stones, quarried from South Africa, were part of her personal jewelry collection as brooches, but they’re not without controversy either: Historians point out that although they were given as gifts to King Edward VII, the near-flawless diamonds remain artifacts of British imperialism.

“The decision to exclude the Kohinoor from the crowns used in the ceremony strikes me as an attempt to keep questions about British colonial exploitation and the royal family’s involvement in that exploitation to a minimum,” said Danielle Kinsey, assistant professor of history at Carleton University in Ottawa, Ontario, which focuses on the history of 19th-century Britain and its empire. “They can’t escape that history.”

The Kohinoor, also spelled Koh-i-noor, was first placed on Queen Mary’s crown and later replaced with a quartz crystal replica, while the original was moved to the Queen Mother’s crown, where is found now. according to the Royal Collection Trust.

The Cullinan, the largest diamond in the world, it was discovered in South Africa in 1905 in a mine near one of the three capitals, Pretoria. The diamond was cut into nine large stones and some 100 small ones, including the 530-carat Star of Africa, which is set in the Sovereign’s Scepter with Cross. The scepter is presented to the sovereign during his coronation. All gems are part of the Crown Jewels of the United Kingdom.

the culinano was gifted to the royal family in 1907 as a symbolic gesture to mend the relationship between Great Britain and the Republic of South Africa after a war broke out between the two.

Kinsey said the stone highlights European exploitation of resources such as diamonds and gold in Africa, and its lasting impact.

“Although the royal family’s acquisition of the Cullinan has stronger legal grounds than the Kohinoor acquisition,” he said, “it still raises the question of the royal family’s involvement in the development of diamond resource development in the South Africa”.

Kinsey pointed to the fact that the Cullinan was a reconciliation gift from the South African government, unlike the Kohinoor diamond, which he said was acquired under duress.

Kinsey said he thinks people will continue to talk about the diamond of almost 106 carats coronation day regardless.

Image: Queen Mary's crown removed from the Tower of London ahead of coronation
Queen Mary’s crown which has been removed from display at the Tower of London for alteration work ahead of the coronation of King Charles III and the Queen Consort.Buckingham Palace/Royal Collection Trust via Getty Image

She said the decision to incorporate three of the Cullinan diamonds would not dodge the issue of British colonial exploitation and could instead backfire and open up an even more urgent conversation about returning the loot.

“If the Kohinoor is a symbol of the plundering imperialism of the East India Company in India, the Cullinan is a symbol of a different kind of British racialized settler colonialism in South Africa, and the royal family and their crowns and literal badges are a place where these two tensions of imperialism come together,” he said.

Buckingham Palace cited “sustainability and efficiency” in its press release for the decision to reinstate the existing crown rather than commission a new one.

The decision comes months after a resurgence in demands calling on Britain to return the Kohinoor to the Indian government following the death of Queen Elizabeth II.

The statement did not acknowledge political or diplomatic reasons. Buckingham Palace did not respond to NBC News’ request for comment.

The Kohinoor, which means “Mountain of Light”, was probably discovered in southern India in the 13th century. It worked its way through several dynasties, beginning with the Mughals in the 16th century, then the Persians, and then the Afghans before reaching the Sikh Maharaja Ranjit Singh in 1813.

India’s Governor-General forced Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s 10-year-old son and successor, Maharaja Duleep Singh, to “gift” the diamond to Queen Victoria in 1849, according to private letters from the general seen by NBC.

The push for Britain to return the diamond is not new. Various countries have claimed the diamond over the years, though modern borders make the process difficult. India, Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan have repeatedly demanded that the British hand it over.

Adrienne Munich, author of “Empire of Diamonds: Victorian Gems in Imperial Settings” and emeritus professor of English at Stony Brook University, said that while she’s not sure if there’s any real mystery behind the decision to replace the diamond, it’s hard to believe it’s just a fashion statement.

Munich said the reason was probably as simple as not wanting to create more controversy with the diamond display. She believes that there will be attention on the stone regardless of its presence.

“Symbols often seem to be more powerful or equally powerful than whatever reality we are dealing with,” he said.

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like