WASHINGTON — A lawyer for Republican donor Harlan Crow has told Senate Judiciary Democrats that the billionaire businessman will not provide them with information about his relationship with Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas.
Michael D. Bopp, Crow’s attorney, told Chairman Dick Durbin, D-Ill., in a letter Monday that he believes the committee does not have the authority to “investigate Mr. Crow’s personal friendship with Judge Clarence thomas”.
Congress “does not have the constitutional power to impose rules and standards of ethics on the Supreme Court,” Bopp wrote. “To do so would exceed the authority of Article I of Congress and would violate basic principles of separation of powers. That precludes the Committee from conducting an investigation in support of such legislation.”
In response, Durbin issued a statement saying the letter “did not provide credible justification for Mr. Crow’s and three corporate entities’ failure to respond to the Committee’s written questions.”
“The Committee will respond more fully to this letter shortly and will continue to seek a substantive response to our requests for information to develop and promote the specific ethics legislation needed to help restore confidence in the Supreme Court,” Durbin said in a declaration. “As I have said many times before: The Chief Justice has the power to set a credible and enforceable code of conduct for the Court today. However, if the Court does not act, this Committee will.”
Bopp’s argument for not complying with the committee mirrored what he told the Senate Finance Committee earlier this month. The panel had requested a list of the gifts Crow had given Thomas, but Bopp argued that the committee lacked a legislative purpose in its request for such a list.
He said that “the Supreme Court has explicitly stated that Congress has no authority to engage in police investigations or to conduct investigations designed to expose the private affairs of citizens for the sake of exposing them.”
Durbin and other Democrats on the Judiciary Committee asked Crow to provide an itemized list of gifts worth more than $415 that he gave to Thomas or any other judge or their relatives. They also asked Crow to provide a complete list of real estate transactions, transportation, lodging, and admission to private clubs that he could have provided.
Thomas has come under fire over allegations reported by ProPublica that he failed to adequately disclose trips and gifts paid for by Crow, the sale of the estates of Thomas and his relatives to Crow, and the tuition Crow had paid for one of the judge’s relatives.
Thomas said after ProPublic’s reports that he had been told the trips and gifts were “personal hospitality from close personal friends” and did not have to be reported in the disclosures.

