Alabama graduating students mourn their classmates killed at Sweet 16

Alabama graduating students mourn their classmates killed at Sweet 16

DADEVILLE, Ala. — Raven Tolbert, a Dadeville native, returned to her hometown after graduating college to fulfill her dream of establishing a dance studio, Mahogany Masterpiece, dedicated to children and youth.

On April 15, the red brick building on Broadnax Street opposite the courthouse and police station, right in the center of town, became a scene of carnage. His vinyl sign is gone, the store front is festooned with a makeshift memorial of flowers. That Saturday night, during a Sweet 16 party there, six gunmen fired a total of 89 shots. They destroyed the small community in a matter of seconds.

The shooters killed Dadeville High students Shaunkivia Smith, 17, and Philstavious “Phil” Dowdell, 18; Marsiah Emmanuel Collins, 19, from nearby Opelika; and Corbin Dahmontrey Holston, 23, who graduate of Dadeville High in 2018. Residents of this sleepy town of 3,100, 90 miles southeast of Birmingham, have been reaching out to one another for support as they mourn their loved ones and pray for the recovery of at least 32 others injured in the chaos.

“It breaks my heart,” Tolbert said.

The scene of a shooting at the Mahogany Masterpiece dance studio on May 31, 2023 in Dadeville, Alabama.
The scene weeks after the shooting at the Mahogany Masterpiece dance studio.Curtis Bunn/NBC News

Six weeks after the shooting, the shroud hanging over this small town has slowly begun to lift. Black and gold ribbons representing the high school colors cover business doors and residents’ mailboxes, a symbol that the town remains connected in grief. A painted sign on a store reads, “Dadeville Strong.”

“With time to think about it, it’s still hard to believe that a small place like this could have something like this,” said Tasha Woodward, whose daughter is recovering after being shot. Woodward was reluctant to discuss the incident and would not share the name of her daughter. “It hurts me to talk about it. It’s been very difficult for everyone because pretty much everyone knows everyone, so we’re all suffering.”

Also injured is Martin Collins, whose son, Marsiah, did not make it out of the building alive. Collins, a former US Marine, is in his third year of law school at the University of the South in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and encouraged his son to enroll at nearby Louisiana State University, where it was supposed to start this fall. Marsiah was reluctant to leave Dadeville after graduating from high school last year. But in April, he texted his father: “You’re right. I’m ready to go down there.” Collins was elated. He told his son that he had come to Dadeville to bring him back to Louisiana in mid-May. A few days later, his son was gone. “I can’t help but think that I should have made him come last year,” Collins said. “He would still be alive.”

Mariah Collins.
Mariah Collins.Courtesy of Martin Collins

Woodward said she feels “blessed” her daughter survived. “She has good days and bad days, physically and emotionally. But the love that the community has shown has been more than she could have hoped for,” she said. “If people found out what happened here and forgot about us, that’s fine. Let’s get through this together.”

Black residents make up 45% of Dadeville, according to to the most recent Census Bureau data. There is a high school in this rural community, where most people work in manufacturing plants and shop at Piggly Wiggly or Dollar General. The median income in the city is $24,722.

One faction of the people are football fans of the University of Alabama. Another faction likes Auburn. The competition is friendly, “because a lot of us are related or have known each other our whole lives,” said Ricky Harris, 42, who stood in front of the Mr. Kutz Barbershop, a few blocks from the high school and the scene of the crime.

“I knew every single one of those kids that got shot,” he said. “You see it happening everywhere, but not here. But now you have it. And he has hurt us, but he is also bringing us closer together ”.

At graduation last Thursday night, emotions ran high. The entire graduating class wore personalized shawls and buttons in memory of the two seniors who were supposed to walk across the stage that night. Smith and Dowdell’s parents joined the graduation procession, wearing caps and gowns as they walked down the path meant for their fallen sons. Their senior portraits were placed in the seats they would have occupied. Tears flowed.

“I’m an old man and I cried like a baby,” said Mason Jamison, who moved to Dadeville from Montgomery three years ago, “because it’s smaller and I always enjoyed the feeling here. I didn’t know the people who were shot, but I felt the pain of the city. I felt like I had to go pay my respects to the victims and be around people and hug someone because we’re all hurting.”

The pain Collins feels is tangible at times, he said. She is getting back to being able to eat more than once a day. There are fleeting moments when she feels good. “But then she hits me,” she said. He remembers getting a call about a relative being shot. She immediately tracked down Marsiah’s cell phone. He showed that he was in the shooting building. When someone posted on Twitter an image of the bloody scene inside the bodies scattered on the ground, she recognized his son, if no one else could.

“I could tell by the body language. I just knew,” said Collins, 40. “None of those children deserved to die like this. I did everything I could to protect Marsiah from the streets. And then you get shot at a party? It’s a devastating situation.”

Mourners attend a vigil at Dadeville First Baptist Church following last night's mass shooting at the Mahogany Masterpiece dance studio on April 16, 2023 in Dadeville, Alabama.
Mourners attend a vigil at Dadeville First Baptist Church the day after the mass shooting at the Mahogany Masterpiece dance studio in Dadeville, Alabama.File Megan Varner/Getty Images

Collins said he is furious with the gun violence plaguing the country. He fought in Iraq and Afghanistan and has seen “what a gun does to the body,” he said. “These kids shoot and run and don’t see the damage a bullet does.”

When he visited the morgue, Collins asked to see Marsiah. They advised him not to, but he insisted. “I wanted to see what they did to my son.” They shot him five times, including his face. “In the surreal of the moment, I thought about how much money his mother and I spent on braces for his teeth when he was young. He had such a beautiful smile. And the timing was so crazy that I thought, ‘They ruined my son’s smile.’”

“That is how devastating this is. I was there talking to my son, as if he were here, knowing that he could not answer me. Collins’s voice trailed off.

Already indicting the suspects on four counts of murder, a grand jury returned additional charges in a 145 count indictment against five of the six suspects who were of legal age. The charges include assault on the surviving victims.

“Justice will take care of them,” Collins said of the attackers. “In Dadeville, they will take care of each other. they are suffering. I know. I tell people that things can change in a second. I can be fine once in a while, bam, the next second I have anxiety or I’m crying.“

Woodward recounts.

“It’s hard,” he said, “Dadeville is a small town and the community is hurting. But we are close. Closer than I realized. It will always hurt. But we can hold each other and stay together and get through this nightmare. Together.”


By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like