A lesbian lost her son to her sperm donor. Should other gay parents be concerned?

A lesbian lost her son to her sperm donor.  Should other gay parents be concerned?

A court ruling this week rejecting the custody petition for the son he raised for two years with his estranged wife by an Oklahoma woman should serve as a cautionary tale for same-sex parents, some legal experts say.

Kris Williams and Rebekah Wilson were legally married in June 2019, before Wilson gave birth to a son in August, according to court documents. Shortly after the couple separated in November 2021, Wilson moved in with the boy’s sperm donor, taking the boy with her and leading Williams to file for custody.

If Williams were a man, there would have been a “presumption of paternity” under Oklahoma state law, which reads: “A man is presumed to be the father of a child if…he and the child’s mother are married. each other. and the child is born during the marriage.”

Kris Williams, right, and Rebekah Wilson with their son.
Kris Williams, right, and Rebekah Wilson with their son before their separation.Courtesy Kris Williams

But a judge ruled Monday against Williams, affirming in its decision that the law does not apply to parents in same-sex relationships, because state paternity law predates the legalization of same-sex marriage in the state.

The ruling surprised some legal experts, who noted that the decision is atypical compared to similar cases across the country, and prompted them to advise same-sex couples to take additional steps to secure their parental rights.

“It’s a reminder to same-sex couples that we continue to live in a legal system and a society that isn’t always fair and doesn’t always follow the law,” said Shannon Minter, an attorney with the National Center for Lesbian Rights. she said. “Those couples may face unfair and even illegal obstacles to securing and protecting their parental rights, and that’s just a reality.”

The landmark 2015 Supreme Court decision that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide, Obergefell v. Hodges, found that same-sex couples are entitled to “civil marriage on the same terms and conditions as opposite-sex couples.” Some legal experts, such as Minter, argue that this decision alone should be enough to guarantee married gay couples the same parental rights as their heterosexual counterparts.

Two years later, in June 2017, the high court ruled in Pavan v. Smith that states should extend equal treatment to same-sex parents by requiring the issuance of birth certificates of both parents for children born to same-sex spouses to acknowledge paternity.

Wilson was initially listed on the boy’s birth certificate when he was born in 2019, according to court documents. However, Oklahoma County District Judge Lynne McGuire argued that Williams could not claim parental rights to the child because Oklahoma’s paternity law predates the state’s legalization of same-sex marriage. .

“[The act] it does not take into account same-sex marriage, and there is no presumption that the wife of the mother is automatically presumed to be the parent of a child born during the marriage,” McGuire ruled.

Douglas NeJaime, a family law professor at Yale Law School, disagrees with McGuire’s decision. He argued that even if states have gender-specific parenting rules that were written at a time when same-sex couples couldn’t marry, the Supreme Court’s Obergefell and Pavan decisions require state law to apply to couples. married of the same sex.

“It’s not like you’re looking at two statutes,” NeJaime said, referring to the comparison of the state’s parenting law and Supreme Court decisions. “You’re looking at a statute and a constitutional precedent that now tells you, ‘You have to apply that statute in accordance with this constitutional precedent.'”

In Monday’s ruling, McGuire wrote that the only way Williams could have legally claimed paternity was if he had adopted the child he was raising.

“The reality is that the law provides a legal remedy available to Williams,” McGuire wrote, referring to the adoption. “She knowingly chose not to go through with it.”

Williams, 51, vowed to appeal the judge’s decision and expressed dismay that her sexuality influenced her rights as a mother.

“As a queer person, being invisible, being erased is one of those traumas that we have,” she said, sometimes with a lump in her throat. “So on that level, going through this as a queer person, it’s a recurring trauma of being erased: ‘You’re not important, go away.'”

Williams said she and Wilson began dating in June 2014. The couple began looking for sperm donors for a child in 2018, she added, finding Harlan Vaughn through the Known Donor Registry website and connecting with him on Facebook. In September 2018, according to court documents, Wilson signed a “Known Sperm Donor Agreement” with Vaughn before Wilson’s non-medical insemination took place in December of that year.

The couple chose Vaughn to be their sperm donor because they believed he was gay and had a boyfriend at the time, Williams said. She said she hoped Vaughn could have a “guncle” (gay uncle) relationship with the boy.

“I felt extremely safe,” Williams said. “I never in a million years could have imagined that it would be two people from our community who were going to take these steps, and especially one with whom I was very much in love.”

In October 2021, shortly after the boy’s second birthday, Vaughn moved to Oklahoma City and began spending time with the boy, according to court documents. The following month, Wilson left the couple’s shared home, took his child, and moved in with Vaughn. Wilson and Vaughn have been raising the child together and have since had a second biological child, court documents show. Williams has not seen the boy, now 3, since November 2021.

Vaughn declined an interview request from NBC News, but released a statement on behalf of himself and Wilson: “We remain focused solely on the protection and well-being of our children. We are grateful for the court’s validation.”

Minter and NeJaime said that most custody cases involving the children of same-sex spouses who have separated or already divorced have ended the non-biological father keeping his parental rights, with the exception of the Oklahoma ruling and one Idaho case, Gatsby vs. Gatsbyin 2021.

However, they said that with the Supreme Court’s conservative majority and the rise of anti-LGBTQ state legislation being introduced across the country this year, same-sex parents should do everything they can to protect themselves. When possible, they both suggested, same-sex non-biological parents should adopt their own children or seek a court ruling to guarantee their legal rights as parents.

“It shouldn’t be necessary, and it’s a shame, but it’s a reality in many places,” Minter said.

By Mitchell G. Patton

You May Also Like